Bo Nix Struggles: Average QB, Elite Escape Artist, or Both? The Balz Brothers Go to War
The Broncos are 7-2 and they still give me heartburn. Bo Nix’s struggles are the biggest argument in Broncos Country right now, so my brother Harry and I took it to the kitchen table, which is how the Balz family settles everything. First, the facts: Nik Bonitto secured Denver’s 16th straight one-score win, an NFL record, with a late strip-sack of Bryce Young, sending the division leaders into their bye week at 7-2 atop the AFC West. Notice who made that play. It wasn’t the quarterback.
The Numbers Behind the Bo Nix Struggles
Here’s my opinion, and I’m saying it loud: Nix is painfully average right now. Through nine games he’s at 174 of 287, 60.6 percent, 1,730 yards, 11 TDs, 4 INTs, 84.7 rating. Heading into Carolina, ESPN had his QBR at 48.6, 24th in the league. In four of Denver’s first six games, Nix failed to reach 200 passing yards. That includes the overtime win over Seattle, when the offense managed only two first downs after its early lead and punted seven times.
Even Nix was confused by it. After that game he said, “I don’t understand why we can’t really push the ball vertically right now.”
HARRY: “Jim, you’re the guy who picked the Patriots against Green Bay and watched them give up 45. Nix keeps winning. Against the Chiefs, Denver trailed 24-13 heading into the fourth quarter, but late comebacks are nothing new for Nix.”
Fair enough, Harry. But you picked Colorado over Arizona State, so you don’t get to hand out football wisdom this week. Carolina is my exhibit A. Nix was 25-of-37 for 237 yards and two touchdowns, but he also threw a red-zone interception, and the Panthers later grabbed their only lead of the day early in the third quarter. The quarterback dug a hole and the defense filled it in again.

HARRY: “SI’s film room says he’s finally hunting again. Their player grades say he’s starting to turn a corner.”
A corner, Harry, in Week 9.
Jim’s Broncos Gear
Average QB or not, 7-2 looks good on a hoodie.
As an Amazon Associate, Sports By The Balz earns from qualifying purchases.
What the Bloggers and Fans Are Saying
Both sides have a case. On the worried side:
– Former NFL QB Ryan Fitzpatrick labeled Nix’s play as “garbage” during the postgame broadcast after the Seattle game.
– PFN noted Denver was ranked number 26 in PFN’s Offense Impact Metric back when the team was 4-2.
– One fan’s verdict: “Their offense is a complete mess.”
– Another fan said “Bo Nix is dragging this entire team down.”
– Some fans point to the ankle: “This Bo Nix, after that injury, is a totally different player.”
The defenders blame the whole offense, not just the QB. They point to struggling receiver separation, inconsistent rushing attacks, and tight coverage schemes. Mile High Sports summed up the mood well: fans love the winning but hate the constant short dump-off passing game.
My take: the offense is a group problem, but the quarterback’s job is to rise above it.
Trade Deadline Grade: Daiyan Henley
The Broncos agreed to a deal for linebacker Daiyan Henley from the Chargers, pending a physical, and in return Denver is sending a 2027 fourth-rounder and a 2028 fifth-rounder. GM George Paton reportedly checked in on running back Jonathan Taylor, but Henley was the deal that got done. There was a bit of disappointment that the Broncos didn’t end up swinging a trade for Taylor.
| Balz | Grade | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Jim | B- | Good price, but the offense got no help |
| Harry | C+ | “Bo needed a weapon, not a linebacker” |
I’ll defend the pick cost. One analyst believes the move would not have been done if the Broncos felt like Alex Singleton and Justin Strnad were playing well enough. Still, the side of the ball that needed help got nothing.
Harry’s Raiders Week Shopping List
The Raiders come to town Nov. 22. Harry is already planning the tailgate.
As an Amazon Associate, Sports By The Balz earns from qualifying purchases.
Scorecard and Picks
We both picked the Broncos in Charlotte and we were both right. My Bears pick on Sunday night came through too, a 27-24 squeaker over the Bucs, so I’m 21-12 on the season. Harry is 22-17, and I’m coming for him. Next up for Denver: Raiders rookie Fernando Mendoza is set to make his first NFL start against Seattle this week, and then he visits Empower Field on Nov. 22 in the Broncos’ first game off the bye.
Jim’s pick: Broncos.
Harry’s pick: Broncos.
Your turn: Will Bo Nix throw for 250 yards against the Raiders, or does the defense have to bail him out for a 17th straight one-score win? Make your case in the comments (join the Balz Fan Club free to comment and like the best takes). Want the bigger picture beyond the box score? Read The Hairy Times, our sister paper.
Sources we checked (20)
- Bo Nix leads Broncos past Panthers for fifth straight win – CBS Sports
- Bo Nix, Denver Broncos, QB – News, Stats, Bio – CBS Sports
- Bo Nix 2026 Stats per Game – NFL – ESPN
- ‘Better Than I Expected,’ ‘Offense Is a Complete Mess’ …
- Bo Nix Expresses Frustration with Broncos’ Offensive Inefficiency …
- Film Room: Bo Nix Is Finally Hunting Again—and Broncos Are Better …
- Broncos Player Grades vs. Panthers: Bo Nix Is Starting to Turn …
- ‘Absolutely Terrible,’ ‘Dragging This Entire Team Down’ …
- Evaluating Bo Nix and the Offensive Struggles Facing the Denver …
- New criticism of Bo Nix mimics that from defensive coordinators …
- Broncos’ Trade Deadline Review, Panthers Recap & Bye Week Preview …
- Did the Broncos make any other moves at the NFL trade deadline? …
- 3 winners (and 2 obvious losers) from the Broncos trade deadline …
- Recapping the NFL trade deadline for the Broncos – Yahoo Sports
- How NFL trade deadline altered path to Super Bowl
- AP via ABC News: Broncos beat Panthers 26-21 for fifth straight victory
- DenverBroncos.com: Broncos set NFL record with 16th consecutive one-score win
- DenverBroncos.com: Broncos agree to terms on trade for LB Daiyan Henley
- ChicagoBears.com: Bears edge Buccaneers 27-24
- Featured photo: Empower Field at Mile High by Pdubs.94, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Go to the game
Want to see it in person?
Find tickets for upcoming games, home and away.
Sponsored links via Sports Events 365. We may earn a commission.